Yvonne Ridley: Jeremy Corbyn's Labour is still welded to the Tories

CommonSpace columnist Yvonne Ridley says Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn ought to realise he has more in common with the SNP than the Tories

I LIKE Jeremy Corbyn. I like the fact he has not moved his political position one iota while trying to upgrade and turbo charge the dinosaur that was the Labour party when he first became its leader.

I like the fact he rose above his critics and refused to jump in the gutter with them as they and many of his own colleagues in the Parliamentary Labour Party tried every low blow and dirty trick known to the Westminster cabal to oust him.

His unwavering support for the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and his distaste for nuclear weapons - which chimes with the policies of the SNP - is also to be applauded despite the immense pressure from the war-mongering Blairite wing of Labour and the scorn from their Tory friends on the government benches.

The truth is Corbyn has much more in common with the SNP than he does with many of the politicians in Scottish Labour who largely support Tory policies such as Trident renewal.

Even though his revolutionary manifesto during the snap General Election mirrored much of the SNPs policies, I think we all cheered him on in the hope he would beat our common enemy: the Tories.

However, his decision to head to Scotland this coming month has left many of us completely baffled. If it was to sort out the "branch office" that is Scottish Labour I could understand his imminent arrival, but his advisors are briefing that Corbyn will tour SNP-held constituencies to persuade Scots living in marginal seats to switch their allegiance.

Frankly I am bewildered. He is being completely ill advised if he believes some of the 64 Westminster seats needed to win in order to secure a majority are here, in Scotland. The truth is Corbyn has much more in common with the SNP than he does with many of the politicians in Scottish Labour who largely support Tory policies such as Trident renewal.

While I'm a mere foot soldier in the SNP, I'm pretty confident Nicola Sturgeon and her Westminster MPs would rather make an alliance with Corbyn's Labour should he need coalition friends to form a government in the next election. In strategy terms, unless he wants to target Tory seats - something Scottish Labour rarely does - he has no need to come to Scotland since there are far bigger battles to be won south of the border.

Vulnerable seats identified include Glasgow South West; Glasgow East; Airdrie and Shotts; Lanark and Hamilton East; Motherwell and Wishaw; Inverclyde; and Dunfermline and West Fife, where swings of less than one per cent are required for Labour to win while the Westminster number crunchers say a further 10 central belt constituencies would require a swing to Labour of between 1.4-3.6 per cent to change hands to increase their seven seats here.

Visit our donate page to help us fund two new reporters

However, quite why Corbyn appears to be carrying on with the party's unhealthy obsession of attacking the SNP, is beyond comprehension. That obsession aided and abetted the Tories during the last General Election. Surely it is better to target the Tories in Scotland? Such a move would win the admiration of traditional leftwing voters who have felt abandoned by Scottish Labour in recent years.

Mhairi Black might be the youngest MP in Westminster but she is in tune with voters of all ages and has an intuitive knack of cutting through the claptrap to identify the problems. She recently wrote: "We’ve had seven years of Tory austerity that has hammered working families, damaged public services, and targeted cuts at the poorest and most vulnerable.

"That same Tory government now wants to take us off a hard Brexit cliff edge, and shut Scotland out of the EU negotiations, as if our interests simply don’t matter. But instead of focusing their fire on the Tories, Labour spent the whole election campaign obsessed with the SNP, which activists rightly complain let the Tories off the hook and helped them win crucial votes.

If Corbyn insists on heading north with the sole aim of targeting and undermining the SNP then he must answer some really awkward questions.

"This devastating verdict from Labour members themselves should make Kezia Dugdale, and others at the top of the party hierarchy, hang their heads in shame. Their Better Together fixation has made us all worse off, with Scotland now trapped under yet another Tory government."
Black is extremely critical of the way in which those in the PLP have sought to undermine Corbyn, but holding out an olive branch she added: "Instead of attacking the SNP, Labour should be working with us to hold the Tories to account, to oppose austerity, and to drive forward progressive policies."
Corbyn and his advisers should rethink their strategy with regards Scotland. Support from the SNP, should it be needed in a coalition scenario, is virtually guaranteed so if Labour wants to maintain its election footing and build momentum the biggest battles are to be won south of the Border in England and Wales. 
However if Corbyn insists on heading north with the sole aim of targeting and undermining the SNP then he must answer some really awkward questions. For instance, Scotland's large core of Remain supporters still want to know why both the main Westminster parties are wholeheartedly behind Brexit without a thought or concern for a nation of people who made it abundantly clear they are not.

Why is the Labour Leader in England heading to Scotland to target the SNP when the party preventing him from getting the keys to Downing Street is the Conservative party? 

Will he also be able to clear up the confusion over Trident? Scottish Labour is clearly in favour of nukes unlike the Corbynistas - so who can voters trust on Trident? And why does Corbyn support independence movements around the world including the Catalan and Basque call for independence but he doesn't want it for the likes of us here in Scotland?

Perhaps, more importantly, why is the Labour Leader in England heading to Scotland to target the SNP when the party preventing him from getting the keys to Downing Street is the Conservative party? 

The uncomfortable truth is that the Better Together and Brexit ties are still keeping Labour and Tories partners in the same bed ... welded together in one of the most abusive political marriages in history.

Picture courtesy of Garry Knight

Look at how important CommonSpace has become, and how vital it is for the future #SupportAReporter



Wed, 08/02/2017 - 20:33

She is baffled by the Labour leader coming to campaign for Labour to win seats, doesn't take much to baffle her does it? It might be beyond nationalists but socialists care about winning seats in every part of the uk and given the rather dodgy assertion that the SNP are reliable allies for Labour on top of that seeing as a a couple of years of ago the exclamation was that we were all red tories it would be easy to mistake this article for cheap sniping.


Wed, 08/02/2017 - 23:08

So Jeremy Corbyn is coming to Scotland to try to win seats for Labour. How crazy is that?.
Only the SNP can win back the seats they lost to the Tories because of their stupidity in making a vote for the SNP a proxy anti-Brexit vote thus causing SNP Brexiters to vote Tory.
This article just doesn't make sense. Is she saying that Labour shouldn't contest SNP seats?


Thu, 08/03/2017 - 15:15

Actually, I think she is right. If austerity and Brexit are the challenges, then the Tories should be ousted, so those seats should be targeted, especially as they have proved this far not to have Scotland's interests at heart. Labours policies, with the clear exceptions of Trident and Brexit, are broadly similar to the SNP, so it makes no sense to be competing with the same policies, particularly since Scotland has had many of them for longer.

SLabour actively supported the Tories during the GE. In my area and others we had a paper candidate from Labour, depending on the vote strength and it's clear from recent reports that many SLabour activists are unhappy with how that election was fought. Mr Corbyn appears not to have looked at the figures in Scotland. There was a Corbyn bounce here, to win seats, but looking at the figures it appears that SLab's part of the vote showed little change from 2015. Yes the SNP lost seats, but the number of SNP voters who voted because of Brexit are the same as the EU ref +\- 30%. However, Mr Corbyn is visiting marginals across the UK over the summer, not just Scotland. It will be interesting to see how that turns out, particularly since his view on Brexit is as hard as the Tories.

Sceptical Scot

Wed, 08/09/2017 - 13:44

Where do you start with this steaming pile of bowel porridge? I suppose it is yet more evidence of trendy lefty discombobulation. To describe the last labour manifesto as 'revolutionary' is at best an exaggeration, to describe the SNP as revolutionary is downright risible. The author simultaneously misunderstands Brexit, Corbyn, the Labour Party, the SNP, the last election, the post ref political landscape, and everything else she references in this drivel. The arguments of red tories or even more laughable red snp, were shallow 3 years ago, these arguments now, give whole new meaning to to phrase intelectually vapid.....another left nationalist who has whored themselves off the nationalists in the forlorn hope of actually finishing on the winning side, only to discover in defeat, they are not wanted. Back to the smoke filled phone boxes planning the revolution!

CommonSpace journalism is completely free from the influence of advertisers and is only possible with your continued support. Please contribute a monthly amount towards our costs. Build the Scotland you want to live in - support our new media.