Nicola Sturgeon: Independence is "the natural extension" of devolution

Speaking in Edinburgh on the 20th anniversary of the referendum on a Scottish Parliament, the first minister said devolution flows from the same intellectual current as the independence movement

NICOLA STURGEON, speaking in Edinburgh on the anniversary of the 1997 referendum on the re-establishment of the Scottish Parliament, said that “at its heart, independence is the natural extension” of the demands which led to devolution.

Acknowledging Scotland’s divide on constitutional politics and reaffirming her position on Brexit, Sturgeon said: “Everyone knows … that I believe that becoming an independent country would be the best future for Scotland and that, as I said in June at the end of the Brexit process, I believe that the people of Scotland should have a choice about our future direction as a country.

“At its heart, independence is the natural extension of the principle that decisions should be taken in Scotland and that doing so improves the lives of people who live here.” First Minister Nicola Sturgeon

“Indeed, at its heart, independence is the natural extension of the principle that decisions should be taken in Scotland and that doing so improves the lives of people who live here.”

Drawing a connection between the history she stood to commemorate and the political battles ahead between the Scottish and UK Government, Sturgeon said: “The devolution settlement – the Scotland Act that established our parliament – is based on the quite genius principle, when you look back and consider it, that everything is automatically devolved unless it is explicitly reserved.

“The EU Withdrawal Bill turns that principle absolutely on its head. Westminster will decide what areas of already devolved policy will actually remain devolved in the future.

“So on the very day that we should be celebrating devolution, we are also being called upon to defend it.”

“The devolution settlement is based on the quite genius principle that everything is automatically devolved unless it is explicitly reserved. The EU Withdrawal Bill turns that principle absolutely on its head.” First Minister Nicola Sturgeon

In making the case for this defence, the first minister reached out to political opponents and recalled the collaboration which made victory for devolution possible in 1997, when the SNP, Scottish Labour, the Liberal Democrats and the Scottish Greens campaigned for a ‘Yes’ vote against a Tory-dominated ‘No’ campaign.

Sturgeon said: “Even though there is still disagreement – passionate disagreement – about the final destination of our constitutional journey, we should nevertheless seek a new spirit of consensus to match that achieved in 1997.

“Twenty years ago that disagreement about the final destination did not stop us from working together to make progress where we could, and it shouldn’t stop us today either.” First Minister Nicola Sturgeon

“With Brexit now threatening the underpinning principle of devolution and many of our vital national interests, it is essential that we do so.

“Twenty years ago that disagreement about the final destination did not stop us from working together to make progress where we could, and it shouldn’t stop us today either.”

In the coming months, the Scottish Government will publish a series of policy papers arguing for the extension of the Scottish Parliament’s powers on areas including trade, employment and immigration.

“The more powers our parliament has, the more we can, collectively, do for Scotland,” Sturgeon said.

Responding to the speech, interim Scottish Labour leader Alex Rowley appeared to agree with Sturgeon’s entreaty to defend against a Westminster power grab, but repeated calls by opposition leaders for the Scottish Government to do more with the powers the Scottish Parliament already possesses.

“Labour is the party of devolution, and we will not allow the Tories to use Brexit as a Westminster power grab.” Scottish Labour interim leader Alex Rowley

“Labour is the party of devolution, and we will not allow the Tories to use Brexit as a Westminster power grab,” Rowley said.

“We will stand up against Theresa May’s plan to centralise power in the hands of Tory ministers. That is why Labour MPs from across Britain will tonight be voting against the Repeal Bill.

“Scottish Labour adopted federalism as our party policy in February, and will continue to look at the devolution of powers around employment, immigration and international trade.

“Twenty years on from Scotland voting for a Scottish Parliament with tax raising powers the people of Scotland quite reasonably in my view, expect our government in Edinburgh to use the powers of our parliament. The priority for Nicola Sturgeon and her government must be using the powers to address the big challenges in our NHS, in education, in the economy and in our communities."

Also responding to the speech, Scottish Greens co-convenor and MSP Patrick Harvie echoed sentiments from both Sturgeon and Rowley while making a case for the Green presence in Holyrood, saying: “It's now unthinkable that Scotland wouldn't have its own parliament and it’s clear that in the last 20 years Scotland is continuing to make positive advances in self-government.

“However, the campaign for more powers must come with a renewed determination from any governing party to use them.

“The campaign for more powers must come with a renewed determination from any governing party to use them.” Scottish Greens co-convenor Patrick Harvie

“The anniversary coincides with a critical moment as the UK prepares to fundamentally undermine the devolution settlement via a power grab Repeal Bill and it remains unclear what the consequences will be if Westminster kills off the principle of legislative consent and unilaterally introduces huge new constraints on the Scottish Parliament.

“It would have been inconceivable in 1997 that our parliament would have signalled the end of petrol and diesel cars in just two decades. It’s also unthinkable that these milestones, including the exploration of a universal basic income, would have happened so soon without electing a strong Green contingent.”

Picture courtesy of allstairas

Look at how important CommonSpace has become, and how vital it is for the future #SupportAReporter

Comments

Nelson

Mon, 09/11/2017 - 16:42

I think continued local devolution is the natural continuation of devolution.

MauriceBishop

Tue, 09/12/2017 - 00:11

"I believe that the people of Scotland should have a choice about our future direction as a country."

It is like 2014 never happened for some people.

Peter Dow's picture

Peter Dow

Tue, 09/12/2017 - 00:44

"Quite genius" or haggis-eating surrender monkey? You decide.
___
“The devolution settlement is based on the quite genius principle that everything is automatically devolved unless it is explicitly reserved."
- First Minister Nicola Sturgeon
___
There's no devolution "settlement" as far as supporters of Scottish independence are concerned. Only unionists have "settled" for devolution.

If the First Minister is reading out speeches which praise "settling" for devolution then either she needs to sack her unionist speech writer or the SNP needs a new leader.

There's nothing "quite genius" about reserving macro-economic powers to Westminster, as I believe the Scotland Acts have attempted to do, because it offers a legal pretext for the UK Treasury to impose bad fiscal frameworks on the Scottish government which deny the macro-economic powers, such as borrowing powers which are needed to invest for growth and prosperity.

Rather what would be "quite genius" would be for the Scottish government to refuse agreement to any fiscal framework which denies the necessary macro-economic borrowing powers.

Instead of that real genius we have a First Minister who has surrendered her agreement to the fiscally conservative, economically illiterate Sturgeon / Osborne Fiscal Framework Agreement of February 2016.
_____

And who is the First Minister and her speech writer to speak about "genius" anyway?

Like they'd know? LOL.

Chips with your haggis, First Minister?

peterabell

Wed, 09/13/2017 - 12:44

History didn't stop in 19 September 2014. Democracy is a process, not an event. Something that anti-democratic British nationalists simply cannot comprehend.

peterabell

Wed, 09/13/2017 - 12:46

"There's no devolution "settlement" as far as supporters of Scottish independence are concerned. Only unionists have "settled" for devolution."

We were assured during the first independence referendum campaign that devolution was a process. Seems that was just another British nationalist lie.

peterabell

Wed, 09/13/2017 - 12:59

“At its heart, independence is the natural extension of the principle that decisions should be taken in Scotland and that doing so improves the lives of people who live here.” - First Minister Nicola Sturgeon

But that is NOT the principle behind devolution. Devolution is NOT about having decisions made in Scotland. Devolution is entirely about withholding decision-making powers which should rightly rest with the democratically elected Scottish Parliament.

Devolution is a device by which the power of the British state is preserved and entrenched, while democratic dissent is 'accommodated'.

The principle which informs devolution is not democratic, as the principle of independence is. Devolution perpetuates the principle of parliamentary sovereignty. Devolution is a denial of popular sovereignty.

The 'principle' underpinning devolution is that the democratically elected Scottish Parliament, and the duly mandated Scottish Government, can be overruled by a clique of British politicians with absolutely no democratic legitimacy whatever.

To anyone with so much as a modicum of respect for democracy, this is intolerable.

Christinehubbard

Wed, 09/27/2017 - 09:10

Three months ago I constantly had to go to the bathroom. I thought it was because I gave up soft drinks and was only drinking water. One day I had a stomachache. I was in bed for 4 days. The doctor's appointment was for a Wednesday. I got sick and went to emergency room on a Monday. I was told my blood sugar level was 810 and I have diabetes. Since then, I eat better, take better care of myself and went from 260 to 220 lbs.and was thirsty all the time. One day I got extremely sick, could not keep anything down, had blurry vision, a rapid heartbeat, and began hyperventilating. taking metformin 1000 mg twice daily. I am writing this to inform others that nothing was really working to help my condition.I went off the metformin (with the doctor’s knowledge) and started on Diabetes herbal formula i ordered from Health Herbal Clinic, my symptoms totally declined over a 5 weeks use of the Diabetes natural herbal formula. i am now doing very well, Visit there website www. healthherbalclinic. net or email Info@ healthherbalclinic. net

CommonSpace journalism is completely free from the influence of advertisers and is only possible with your continued support. Please contribute a monthly amount towards our costs. Build the Scotland you want to live in - support our new media.