“Damning” findings on causes of poverty shows the Scottish Parliament “has failed the poorest Scots on housing”

Evidence points to a “growing class divide” in housing

A “COMPLETE OVERHAUL” of the Scottish Government’s approach to housing is needed, as “damning” findings show rising housing costs for the poorest Scots since devolution has become a key impediment to reducing poverty.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s new Poverty in Scotland 2017 report has revealed reductions in poverty over the past two decades is in danger of “unravelling” due to rising housing costs, stagnant wages and welfare cuts.

Since Scotland voted for devolution 20 years ago, the cost of housing for the poorest fifth of Scots has risen significantly, with those paying more than one-third of their income on housing costs increasing from 24 to 37% in that time.

That increase in the burden of housing costs for those on low incomes compares badly with England, which used to be more unaffordable than Scotland but is now level-pegging - the same figures south of the border are 30 to 37%.

Meanwhile the burden of housing costs for middle and upper income households in Scotland has remained stagnant and at a low level over the same period, as the JRF graph below shows.

Commenting on the findings, Common Weal head of policy Ben Wray, author of recent report on living in the private rented sector, stated: “These findings are really damning for the Scottish Parliament, which across successive governments since devolution began has claimed the social justice mantle but has failed the poorest Scots on housing.

“We can lament the UK Government’s failure to raise wages and their barbaric cuts to social security, but housing has been something that has been within the Scottish Parliament’s power to change and it is an indictment that over the past 20 years the problem of housing costs pushing Scots into poverty has continually increased in severity.

“Our record is so bad that we have went from housing costs being less of a burden on the poorest in Scotland than England 20 years ago, to matching England today.

“A complete overhaul is needed of the Scottish Government’s approach to housing. It is no longer tenable to claim that you want affordable housing without confronting rising house prices and the growth of the private rented sector. Affordability is not possible without tackling inequality.” Ben Wray

“It is impossible to avoid the growing class divide in housing: while the poorest Scots have seen costs continually rising, those on middle and high incomes have experienced little change over the past 20 years, with the burden of housing costs remaining low.

“A complete overhaul is needed of the Scottish Government’s approach to housing. It is no longer tenable to claim that you want affordable housing without confronting rising house prices and the growth of the private rented sector. Affordability is not possible without tackling inequality.

“Three policy measures would be a good start: stop subsidising property developers to build for rent and instead expand investment in public housing; get rid of the council tax and introduce a property/land tax that acts as a disincentive on investment in property for speculation and reduces land values; and set-up a proper system of rent controls which ensures the cost of rents are affordable for everyone.”

Comments

Conrad Hughes

Thu, 11/30/2017 - 16:21

It would be nice to hear whether you feel this is a straight up and honest report: ever since Joseph Rowntree bailed out the liar Carmichael and it came out that part of the organisation seemed to be run for the benefit of the Liberal Democrats, I've been worried that their output will be politically tainted. Some reassurance on this point, for this report, would be gladly received.

Jon Dess

Thu, 11/30/2017 - 20:56

Why pick on one aspect of the report - elsewhere it congratulates the Scottish government on reducing poverty compared to the UK/English government that has presided over a rise.

gbuttars

Fri, 12/01/2017 - 21:36

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation and the Joseph Rowntree Trust are separate organisations. The Foundation had nothing to do with the Carmichael affair.

Whitfur

Wed, 12/06/2017 - 01:37

"It is impossible to avoid the growing class divide in housing:" what do you mean growing class divide? There has always been a "class divide" in housing not just in Scotland but across the UK!
Firstly, I get it that the housing situation is not to be commended however, nowhere within this artlcle is there any mention of the fact that this govt stopped the sale of council/social hosing and has brought in new regulation of the private sector. You wouldn't go amiss to give praise where it is due before you offer measures that you think would help to remedy the housing problems!
There is nothing wrong with a private rented sector as long as it is regulated and rents kept at affordable levels.

ejfj's picture

ejfj

Wed, 12/06/2017 - 21:16

The Scottish Government's room for manoeuvre is limited and in financial matters, there are many hidden pitfalls that the British Nationalists would love to see it fall into.

So: thanks to the Rowntree people for identifying some problems, insofar as they have correctly identified them and correctly attributed responsibility for not solving them - but I take anything and anyone chanting SNPBAAAAAAAD with a larger than usual dose of salt, and wonder what their proposals are for improving matters.

"This is bad and we're against it" is not a useful contribution.

CommonSpace journalism is completely free from the influence of advertisers and is only possible with your continued support. Please contribute a monthly amount towards our costs. Build the Scotland you want to live in - support our new media.