Sammy Stein: The US is not the first world power to recognise Jerusalem as Israel's capital, so why the outrage?

Sammy Stein of Glasgow Friends of Israel believes President Donald Trump's controversial recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital could be a help, rather than a hindrance, to peace

DESPITE the furore of President Donald's Trump's decision to recognise Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, there was a notable lack of any condemnation when Russia did exactly the same thing earlier this year. 

The decision, taken by Russia in April 2017, made it the first country in the world to extend such a recognition to any part of the city.

It is thought that Russia’s decision was then reinforced by the response from questions to Google confirming that Jerusalem is the capital Israel. It is also well known that most school children all over the world are taught in geography lessons that the capital of Israel is Jerusalem.

READ MORE: Sturgeon joins SNP activists in condemning Trump's "reckless and wrong" decision on Jerusalem

In fact, no country in the world recognises or 'non-recognises' any other country’s capital but leaves it to each individual nation to decide

There are 124 countries involved in territorial disputes, including numerous occupations: some considered legitimate, some not. Yet 123 of those countries choose their own capitals without any question from the rest of the world. Only Israel is treated differently. Why?

In November 1977, President Sadat of Egypt was the first Arab leader to recognise Jerusalem as Israel’s capital. Sadat visited Israel as part of the peace agreement between the two countries and addressed the Israeli government in the Knesset. Since then numerous world leaders have made official visits to the Israeli capital when meeting the president or prime minister of the country.

The statement made by Donald Trump is therefore no more than a recognition of the facts on the ground and has no impact on issues that require actual negotiations during peace talks between the Israelis and Palestinians. 

Does anyone really imagine that peace talks would include a demand by the Palestinians to move the Knesset or the prime minister’s office from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv, and that Jerusalem will no longer be the capital of Israel?

The smart move would be to see Trump’s decision as the door to compromise on Jerusalem and I support and call for the recognition of east Jerusalem as the capital of the future Palestinian state.

If the Palestinians are serious about peace, they could realistically plan to make east Jerusalem their capital and Trump did not rule this out. In fact, he did not discuss the boundaries of Jerusalem and therefore this aspiration is still possible if only the Palestinians would agree to enter peace negotiations.

The decision by Trump will only hamper peace if others insist it should. Trump confirmed that the United States supports "a two-state solution if agreed to by both sides". Why don’t the Palestinians put him to the test?

The smart move would be to see Trump’s decision as the door to compromise on Jerusalem and I support and call for the recognition of east Jerusalem as the capital of the future Palestinian state.

By their condemnation of the Trump statement, the Palestinians reinforce the view held by many Israelis that there is little to be gained by negotiating with the Palestinians if they do not accept that Jerusalem is the eternal capital of Israel.

And why now? Why did Trump make his declaration now? Could it be because the peace talks have stalled and require a jump start? President Obama tried to push Israel to show more initiative and more flexibility towards the Palestinians but he did not succeed. That was probably because he wasn’t seen by Israel as a true friend. 

By following the Russians and recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, it is likely that Trump will be recognised by Israel as a real friend and he will be in a better position to influence its leaders to take positive steps towards peace talks.

Let’s hope the Palestinians do not once again miss an opportunity for lasting peace.

Picture courtesy of Chris Yunker

Look at how important CommonSpace has become, and how vital it is for the future #SupportAReporter



Mon, 12/11/2017 - 18:47

And why now? Why did Trump make his declaration now?

Because Mueller is closing in on him and his primary defence is feeding his rabid base, which includes crazy evangelicals. It has nothing to do with peace or solutions in the Middle East. Trump doesn't give a rat's arse about Jews or Palestinians.

Dave Coull

Mon, 12/11/2017 - 18:55

Sammy Stein asks why there is so much concern over the USA doing something Russia and others have already done. The answer is, because the USA is very different. The USA has around fifty million evangelical protestant Christians. Regardless of what Trump himself believes, he knows what they believe. They believe in the predictions in the Book of Revelations. They believe in Armageddon. They believe in the end of the world. They believe Jerusalem has to be the capital of Israel, because that is one of the Signs of The End. One of the signs of the Second Coming. They believe Jerusalem should the the capital of the Jews, but, when Christ returns, those Jews who accept him as the Messiah will be saved; and those Jews who don't will be damned. The prospect of war in the middle east, the prospect of global war, even global nuclear war, is to be welcomed, so far as they're concerned, because it says in Revelations this is necessary for the Triumphant Second Coming of Christ. They believe it doesn't matter how many get killed, or how destructive Armageddon is for the environment, or how radio-active the planet becomes, because, with one wave of his hand, Christ can make it all right again. For those who believe in him. And the rest can go to Hell.


Mon, 12/11/2017 - 20:00

And those evangelicals vote for Republicans. If those voters are behind Trump, Republicans, who are a majority in both the house and senate, will be less likely to support impeachment. If they don't they risk getting booted and replaced by even more right-wing replacements.

Trump's foreign policy is driven almost entirely by Trump's short-term domestic political needs.

Jon Dess

Tue, 12/12/2017 - 15:11

Trump is just sucking up to his fascist friend - Netanyahu. Trump loves hard-right hard men such as Bibi (they are both as corrupt as each other) and will do anything to help him.

CommonSpace journalism is completely free from the influence of advertisers and is only possible with your continued support. Please contribute a monthly amount towards our costs. Build the Scotland you want to live in - support our new media.