Former MSP backs land reform campaign to map communities lost in the Highland Clearances

Rob Gibson argues that proposals to assess ‘no-longer-existing-communities’ for resettlement deserve funding

FORMER SNP MSP Rob Gibson has endorsed the mapping of Scottish communities destroyed in the Highland Clearances as part of a radical resettlement plan by land reform group Community Land Scotland (CLS).

Gibson, a former MSP for Caithness, Sutherland and Ross who previously chaired the Scottish Parliament’s rural affairs committee, has argued that official funding should be provided to match the £100,000 spent by Scottish Natural Heritage mapping Scottish wild land in 2014.

Gibson’s comments come in the wake of a number of proposals made CLS, which represents Scotland’s community buy-outs.

Gibson told the Press & Journal: “Recent proposals from Community Land Scotland for repopulation and resettlement of ‘no-longer-existing communities’ deserve analysis to match the time and effort given by government and MSPs to the SNH wild land mapping exercise.

“Agency support to map the extent of previously occupied lands must be made available.” Rob Gibson

“It is clear to me that human settlements and rewilding go hand-in-hand and are not mutually exclusive.

“Agency support to map the extent of previously occupied lands must be made available to match the costs rung up by SNH for their wild land mapping project.

“I raised the issue with SNH when I was an MSP and I believe now is the time to match this public spend on the repopulation issues proposed by CLS. The background work needed to underpin the repopulation plans deserves public funding.”

In response to the draft Planning (Scotland) Bill - which local government and housing minister Kevin Stewart has said will “transform Scotland’s planning system and empower communities to have a greater influence over their future” - CLS suggested a package of measures including the amendment of the bill to allow ministers and communities to employ compulsory purchase powers.

In their submission to the Scottish Government regarding the planning bill, CLS wrote that there “are many areas of Scotland, particularly (but by no means only) in the Highlands and Islands, where vast tracts of land are unpeopled as a result of the (often forcible) removal of people from the land in past centuries.

READ MORE: Rob Gibson MSP: Amending stage of the Land Reform Bill – a time for sustainable development

“The principal straths of Eastern Sutherland (Strathnaver, the Strath of Kildonan and Strathbrora), for example, contain the sites of between 150 and 200 separately named (and sometimes substantial) communities which have been entirely deserted since their occupants were evicted and their buildings levelled in the opening decades of the nineteenth century. Much the same is true of lots of similar localities.

“While not wishing to recreate the land-use patterns of former times, CLS has an ambition the reoccupation of at least some of Scotland’s unpeopled places. At present, this would seem an unlikely proposition, partly, in our view, because land use planning policy does not really contemplate such a possibility.

“This in part is conditioned by landscape policy thinking, and more generally because this strategic land use opportunity has not received the policy attention it probably should have in the past.”

Commenting on Gibson’s endorsement and the CLS proposals, Common Weal head of policy Ben Wray told CommonSpace: "Mapping towns wiped out by the Highland Clearances as the starting point for a strategy to repopulate the Highlands is a fine idea. It should be combined with a publicly available register of land ownership and values so we know who owns it and how much it is worth.

“The use of compulsory purchase powers for redevelopments would be essential to take a repopulation strategy forward.” Common Weal head of policy Ben Wray

“The use of compulsory purchase powers for redevelopments would be essential to take a repopulation strategy forward, and would be significantly enhanced if local authorities could capture the uplift in land value when residential planning permission is granted, as Common Weal proposed in its submission to the Planning Bill.

“This approach was used to build the New Towns of East Kilbride and Cumbernauld - there's no reason it could not be used to re-establish Highlands towns today."

The John Muir Trust also commented, saying the conservation charity “sees no contradiction between the proposals brought forward by Community Land Scotland to open up previously occupied places for people to live and the continued protection for Wild Land Areas”.

Picture courtesy of Colin Campbell

Look at how important CommonSpace has become, and how vital it is for the future #SupportAReporter 



Mon, 02/12/2018 - 17:47

This would be a great start to repopulating many areas.

We could combine this with using the labour of new immigrants. Give them immigration rights if they work X number of years rebuilding communities such as these, with services, roads, etc.

If only we had the political will to do such progressive stuff in this country.

John Stuart Wilson

Mon, 02/12/2018 - 20:58

The SNP have made Scotland the highest taxed part of the UK and are now determined to fritter away the extra money they extract from average Scots on pointless exercises.

Wylie Horn

Mon, 02/12/2018 - 21:08

Meg Douglass did a great job of mapping the lost townships on Mull, Ulva, Gometra, and Lunga in her book 'Lost Townships, Silent Voices',

Bill White

Mon, 02/12/2018 - 22:41

@ John Stuart,

What's wrong with paying tax John?


Tue, 02/13/2018 - 00:43

John, does your analysis take account of Council tax?
Scotland rises to be up to 3%
England rises to be up to 6%.
Or how about the fact that those on a low income will pay less income tax, so there is no real 'across the board' change?
Average wage in Scotland is £23,150 (2017). So you'd have to be in the top half of earners to be affected by the intermediate or higher rates, and the effects are negligible until you get to those earning £35,000 plus.

"Overall, 70% of Scottish taxpayers will pay less, while 55% will pay less than they would if they lived elsewhere in the UK." - BBC.

And of course those comments are purely about income tax.


Tue, 02/13/2018 - 10:46

I don't know why trolls like you are allowed on here. You're like a dementor from Harry Potter, sucking all good feelings away from any situation. Presumably MI5 pays you sufficiently to compensate for immersing yourself in negativity.


Tue, 02/13/2018 - 10:48

Yes, I found the ruined remains of villages on Ulva particularly poignant. Hopefully if the buy-out works out this would be a great place to try this sort of initiative.


Wed, 02/14/2018 - 00:01

Repopulation of the Straths is the way to go, but it runs up against sustainability -ie how to create a community from scratch with both the jobs and services it needs. To be viable, jobs require the raw materials they require to be available locally. Services require a community large enough to be able to support them. In other words - very careful planning, a degree of control about the skills residents should bring, and a degree of committment. Otherwise you just end up with a township of holiday homes where the young people move out as soon as they can. In which case, you might as well not bother.
The varying attempts at sustainability in the islands over the years show that the task is not easy. Which is not to say it should not be taken on.

CommonSpace journalism is completely free from the influence of advertisers and is only possible with your continued support. Please contribute a monthly amount towards our costs. Build the Scotland you want to live in - support our new media.